Trade Tuesday #05: Bell, Cooper, Caldwell
Chew is bullish on Bell, bearish on Cooper, and not sleeping on Caldwell.
The lull of the NFL offseason continues as we anxiously await the beginning of training camp later this month. Veterans at least have one offseason to draw on, but for upcoming rookies, this is their first test at the highest level. This week features three rookie receivers who took three very different paths to the NFL: one is a 1st-round pick, another is a 3rd-round pick, and the third is undrafted.
Trades were sourced from the Dynasty Daddy trade database. Trades were based on the following settings:
Quarterbacks: 2 (Superflex)
Scoring Format: 1 (Full PPR)
Tight End Premium: 0-0.5
Team Count: 10-12 (Draft pick range noted below extends to 12-team leagues)
Starter Count: 9-11
Bestball: False
Every player has Buys (trade-for) and Sells (trade-away), regardless of whether I am “Bearish” or “Bullish”.
Chris Bell | WR | MIA
📈 Bullish: Chris Bell has the requisite WR-1 size and speed at a dynasty discount and joins a Dolphins depth chart with nothing but opportunity.
It’s easy to be bullish on Chris Bell in dynasty right now, with a torn ACL masking a WR-1 skill set that fell to Round 3. Before the injury, Bell had some first-round buzz out of Louisville, racking up 917 yards in just 11 games and boasting an intriguing blend of size and speed. Miami entered the draft with a massive need at receiver and filled it with multiple players, including Bell, who has the size to line up outside and the contact balance to win after the catch. Behind Malik Washington, the depth chart is his for the taking. Bobby Slowik got a lot out of Nico Collins during his time in Houston, and now he’s calling plays in Miami. Bell’s medical history scared teams off draft weekend, but shouldn’t scare you off your rookie draft board.
➕ To BUY:
Chris Bell + ‘27 1st ←→ Brian Thomas
Getting a 1st in a loaded rookie class and a starting WR is a good price for the BTJ mystery box.
Chris Bell ←→ Keon Coleman
The Keon Coleman experiment has been a rocky one, and if there is anyone still interested, then send him away for Bell.
➖ To SELL:
Chris Bell + Jonah Coleman + ‘28 1st ←→ Drake London
This is simply too cheap to pass up to get a top dynasty receiver like Drake London.
Chris Bell + Brian Thomas ←→ George Pickens
Give me George Pickens fresh off a career season instead of Bell and dynasty’s biggest question mark, Brian Thomas.
Omar Cooper Jr. | WR | NYJ
📉 Bearish: Omar Cooper is fighting Garrett Wilson, Kenyon Sadiq, and Breece Hall for touches in an offense that might not have enough to go around.
Omar Cooper snuck into the 1st round of the NFL Draft and joins a Jets offense in need of additional playmakers. Cooper contributes both as a special-teamer and as a receiver, with the latter primarily out of the slot (with the possibility to work as a flanker). Following the draft, Cooper is left battling Garrett Wilson, Kenyon Sadiq, and Breece Hall for touches. I believe what we saw from Geno Smith last year in Las Vegas was rock bottom, but can a recharged Smith feed all these playmakers? I think Wilson and Hall will get their fair share, and it then becomes a weekly dice roll as to who else steps up. A crowded room in a questionable offense leads to a dynasty sell in Cooper.
➕ To BUY:
Omar Cooper ←→ Jayden Reed + ‘27 3rd
Jayden Reed was re-signed in Green Bay, so there is reason for optimism, but I trust Cooper to hold his value a bit longer if I need to trade him away.
Omar Cooper ←→ Oronde Gadsden + ‘27 2nd
Oronde Gadsden’s stock dipped this offseason, so take advantage of his value while you still can.
➖ To SELL:
Omar Cooper + Keon Coleman ←→ Terry McLaurin
Terry McLaurin is no spring chicken, but I fully expect a bounce-back with a healthy Jayden Daniels.
Omar Cooper + ‘28 1st ←→ DeVonta Smith
Despite my tempered belief in DeVonta Smith’s fantasy ceiling, this is just too good a value to pass up.
Jeff Caldwell | WR | KC
💤 Sleeper: Jeff Caldwell is built like a brick shithouse and runs like the wind, so his suppressed value as an undrafted free agent makes him the perfect dynasty sleeper.
What Jeff Caldwell has as a receiver simply cannot be taught: 6’5” 216 lb frame, with a 4.31 40-yard dash and 99th-100th-percentile catch radius and burst. Caldwell was late to football after a life of fútbol, but years at a smaller FCS college led him to his final collegiate season at Cincinnati. The tall, athletic, bursty receiver is not always the sure thing for fantasy football, as the technical aspects of the position cannot be overstated. But Caldwell has a legitimate reason for having a more raw skill set, as a late convert to football. Undrafted rookies have an uphill climb with less financial investment than drafted players, but Caldwell has a real opportunity to stick on a Chiefs roster that briefly maximized the production of a player like Tyquan Thornton. An undrafted receiver who is taller and faster than most is a dynasty sleeper worth adding to your rosters.
➕ To BUY:
Jeff Caldwell + Parker Washington + Jonathan Brooks ←→ Chase Brown
This is a strong belief in Chase Brown, and I’m simply too high on every one of Caldwell-Washington-Brooks to pass this up.
Jeff Caldwell + ‘27 2nd ←→ Jayden Reed + Adonai Mitchell + ‘27 3rd
I shared my thoughts on Jayden Reed in the Cooper trade, and jumping up a round in the ‘27 rookie draft is a good move.
➖ To SELL:
Jeff Caldwell + Bryce Young + Sean Tucker + ‘27 1st ←→ Patrick Mahomes
This is buy low for a quarterback who will get back on track following his injury, whether it is immediately or it takes a few games.
Jeff Caldwell + James Cook ←→ K.C. Concepcion + Luther Burden
James Cook is the best player in this trade, but the value of K.C. Concepcion and Luther Burden is just too much to pass up and allows for resale value if need be.
So you made it this far, and hopefully you enjoyed it (that’s what she said). If you wouldn’t mind sharing this in your group message with your fellow fantasy football degenerates, I would greatly appreciate it!
If you prefer listening to words rather than reading them, check out the Faux Football Podcast!